admin – Page 15

June 4, 2016 0

input

The following are notes from the Death Art & Anatomy conference at the University of Winchester (04062016)

PANEL B

CAROLINE DIEZYN - "TO TELL THE TODUS THEROPON WITH TUNG WERE FUL TERE"

carvedcadavers.tumblr.com

Toads - simple momento mori to comment on luxuria.

In this paper - double tiered transi tombs, only.

Francois de la Sarraz in Switzerland (late 14th cent.)

12th century writers - body as food for worms.

The Awntyrs off Arthur.

Frogs on mouth, eyes, genitals - rather than spontaneous generation of worms, toads, etc, these were intentional placed to show nature of sins.

Question: genitals or abdomen? ie lust or gluttony?

Worms represented repentance, frogs the sins themselves.

poem (?) - dream vision, dialogue between body and worms. "Greens" greenery + vigour/desire.

Toads - luxuria - terra figure - classical to carolinia - snake mother - sins of flesh - corpulent full breasted - woman/sexuality=carnality - in the 12th century she transformed into luxuria - children (?), breasts more obvious - snakes were first companions, then nurslings, then biting her breasts.

11th cent. manuscript, demon drips her pointed shoes, man pulling up garments approaches from left - toad leaping at her from devil's mouth, revelations.

Monk from st. vicker - perturema

amntyrs off arthur - "ghost"? or corporeal form coming back to life (ie transi resurrection)

luxuria transis are not a franciscan message (give away your wealth) rather, "wear a hairshirt".

but there is more happening when reptiles are involved.

Matthias Grünewald 1434-1494, Flemish Painter of the Gothic Era. The Dead Lovers

skeleton is not gendered. different hats suggest gender & class.

ELLIE PRIDGEON: CONSIDERING CADAVERS IN MEDIEVAL AND POST-REFORMATION WALL PAINTING

Psalter of Robert de Lisle, british library, MS Arundel 83 (c.1310).

3 living, 3 dead, 14th cent. in particular.

located in the nave, so deity had access.

Tarrant Crawford, Dorset (early 14th cent.) - high status paintings.

S shaped sway is common.

Hurstbourne Tarrant Hampshire, 3+3, (14th cent.) again in nave (north aisle).

salisbury cathedral gough map 32 bodleirs library, oxford, refurbishment in 18th cent. hungerford chapel at east end of cathedral.

illustrations of Hungerford Chapel interior in Gough R, Sepulchral monuments (1796). Lady Margaret Hungerford, Robert Lord Hungerford monuments. Near doorway so family saw them, walking in and out.

Death and the Gallant, Gough Map 32, Bodlein Library (late a8th cent.) - "Graceless gallant" ie well dressed, lust and price, "to the dead bodies, cast down thine eye".

Death and Gallant, Llancarfan, Wales, late 15th cent. nave. Death pulls gallant round corner to look at grave. warning image regarding behaviour.

"churches were whitewashed after the reformation and to this day," say people. - NOT TRUE.

Apostles- Creed, Harlington, Derbyshire.

Ten commandments, Ashby st ledgers, northamptonshire.

position of post-ref wall painting (as with medieval) mainly nave, north aisle, south aisle.

'Death', Ashby St Ledgers, Northamptonshire.

By 18th cent., figure painting in churches was more acceptable.

18th cent. death has anvil/hammer + spade for digging graves.

Death, Patricio, Wales, 18th.

Death, Dore Abbey, Herefordshire, early 18th, high status.

Father Time, Dore Abbey. Scythe, hour glass.

Maybe from Rubens Cronus Devouring His Children (1637-38). Anyway out of the classical world.

Old Father Time, Ashby st ledgers, Northamptonshire, 18th cent. Scythe is only reason to know it is father time from 18th cent.

CONCLUSION: Nave location/function of space. Eventual re-adoption of cadaver imagery long after reformation. Medieval cadaver paintings function as warnings regarding earthly pursuits and morality (death and the gallant) but this is NOT SO in reformation which is more about reminding (but not morally) that life is passing - just have to wait for hour glass.

Death (Dore Abbey) is high status - know because spinal column + 2 bones in arm shows anatomical knowledge.

High status known through colour palette - earthy pigments in both types of paintings, low key. Higher status = brighter, weather better, greater range. In medieval + renaissance, pigments are requested in specifics (imported from Afghanistan?).

IVAN CENZI: CADAVER MIRABILIS: ROME'S CAPUCHIN CRYPT AND THE BRIGHT SIDE OF MOMENTO MORI

In italy, direct contact between dead and living is possible.

Chiesa di Santa Maria Immaculates.

1626-1631

17th cent. But medieval influence.

Decoration of crypt 1732-1775.

Marquis de Sade escaping sex scandals, visited crypt and left description.

4000 friars buried here.

הֲבֵל הֲבָלִים הַכֹּל הָבֶל

havel havalim, hakol havel (4th/3rd cent. BCE).

All actions rendered “havel” ie futile, by death.

Eclasiasus most scandalous book.

-Lacked faith in goodness of god's creation.

-Death devoids life of all meaning.

-Evolved into effort to place goodness in afterlife.

-Le Gulf pointing out talking about physical body.

-Changing of wind.

Horatic's Carpe Diem as opposite of Momento Mori.

3 living, 3 dead – first as iconic or literary? Literature: 5 french, 3 german, 1 italian, 1 dutch at same time as artistic (visual) representations were appearing.

Late 13th cent. In engravings, stained glass.

Predates Dans Macabre (or Dans Macabre predates?) by 1 cent.

Origin might have been Lindt + cult of the Maccabees.

"The Martyrdom of the Seven Maccabees" by Antonio Ciseri (1800s)

Maccabees -> proto martyrs.

Macabre -> Maccabees

Dans – all stood in circle and one by one left circle to consider Maccabees.

4th book of Maccabees (not in the greek bible) bros described as doing a dance to exorcise fear of death and torture.

Death & the Maiden – vanity gains modern meaning.

Triumph of death – allegory of plague.

3 ages of (wo)man + 3 stages of corpse.

Leyanasula – life is frail like soap bubble.

Et in Arcadia Ego = even I was in arcadia (utopic land). Either dead man speaking from grave OR death is even present in arcadia, too (ie death speaking).

Intersecting medical, science, religion, art.

Wax figure from 17th cent. -> anatomical __(?) “Jesus was a man down to internal organs.”

”The Good Death” at beginning (?)

St. Francis thanks lord for all. When death comes, he sees death as his sister.

Canticle or the creature 1224.

1. Death of body. 2. Damnation of soul.

6 CHAMBERS. (7th grey is bookshop).

Scatological journey.

Journey up through human body (as journey through chambers).

1st CHAMBER

Quantity of bones arranged. Focus is 3 small skeletons (as the only 3 assembled) – young princess + 2 young brothers.

”Death has no age limit”.

Winged hour glass = “time flies”.

Medieval = that which you are we were what we are you will be ie 3 dead.

On the ceiling – scythe + scales enclosed by almost shape (fish bladder) polysenic symbol: “glory of god” + embyro in womb. Death as seed in womb = we start dying as soon as we are born / death is seed of new life (Franciscan, death's door).

2nd CHAMBER (tibias + femurs, leg crypt).

Burial ground underneath, bones arranged... space was tight. Franciscan coat of arms.

3rd CHAMBER (pelvis crypt).

Mummification (catacomb of polemo is the largest collection of mummies, around 12000).

4th CHAMBER (skull crypt).

Symbol of universe.

Last spinal bone 'Atlas', greek god, holding up earth.

Good equaliser.

Actors lower their masks.

Theatrical display.

5th CHAMBER (penance).

Chapel for mass, penance. No bones. Painting of holy mary.

6th CHAMBER (resurrection crypt).

Hope. 3 theological virtues.

DECORATIVE.

Clocks = fleeting time / eternity.

Cross.

7 point star = virgin, holy mary.

Winged hourglass (time flies.)

Winged skull (might seem like macabre version of angel but NOT, rather triumph of soul over body. Soul flying towards absolute or salvation.)

Bones are not only friars' but transfixed, transfigured, symbols representing “all”. What is beautiful, must be great.

Chapel makes death worthy of being admired. Striking to modern sensibilities. Death is not only accepted but admired.

Almost shape – tarot card – the world (garland) – accomplishment and finality – mostly around figure of christ – SEED.

Owners of bones? Cabitchen friars only. They could not be buried in same ground as seculars (aside from 1 exception – niece of pope whose mummified heart is in the penance (5th) chamber.

Public was allowed in (for prayers and mass), at least those devoted to the order had access.

Side chapels? From right nave of church, descent into crypt nut not thought of as on the itinerary.

Mummies in crypt – technique? After spontaneous mummification , friars developed method, specially formed(?) corpses, and drained (seated or in other positions). Central / southern italy. Bodily fluids drain for 8 months to a year. Then cleanse, aroma, dry in sun, close orifices with straw or other.

CAROL RAWCLIFFE: DEATH IN THE LATE MEDIEVAL HOSPITAL

Leprosy.

John Guy – exasperation about hospital historians “Guards van rather than van guard.”

Over 1300 medieval English hospitals.

Sick, elderly, disabled, poor (unlike today).

Norwich, St Giles (unesco hospital archive) around 60 patients.

Hospitals, like monasteries, so disappear at reformation.

St Leonard's, York, 200+ patients.

St Mary Bishop's, destroyed at reformation. Small leper hospitals (stewbridge, cambridge), pilgrim hospitals, after black death – alms houses (care for elderly first issue).

Most were religious institutions (so vulnerable to protestant reform).

Rich man camel needle.

17th canto divine comedy dante – serpent tail.

Dives Nazareth. Luke 16. colours. Nazareth at door. Dives sets dogs on him -> goes to heaven. “Rich man no pity of poor folk.”

feed, water, clothe, visit prisoners (lepers are prisoners in their own bodies)/sick, receive homeless, bury dead.

1st requirement in medieval hospital = confession (particularly urgent after black death).

Hospitals caught between rising wages and falling rates.

Growing desire for funerary spectacle.

”celestial capital”.

Cartesian volume – ascent from purgatory / celestial bucket.

Richard Wittington – financer – loans to crown. 3 x mayor of London – alms house, principle concern: state of soul. Wittington on deathbed (drawing?) Too late for medicine, glass in background, when urine is black yer a goner. Poor praying Witt's soul out of purgatory.

Bart's hospital in Smithfield.

Window depicting 7 comfortable works. Gatehouse bares patrons' coat of arms. Who do you pray for?”

Durham hospital – heraldic arms of Bishop Burry + Edward Howard <-- poor not to forget who they must pray for.

Savoy hospital, Henry 7th. “A view of the Savoy from the River Thames” (drawing?) Tudor roses. Coat of arms even on bedspreads!

St Cross in Winchester (Beaufort's) kneeling beside v. Mary, completed 1446. Had full confidence in hierarchies of this world + influence on next.

Humbleness/pride. Give wealth to poor / advertise.

Donors could even be not very rich. Just a little was enough for their name to be written in the “book of the dead” - Morte legium – which was held up beside the chapel during mass. Entry originally says “Prayers in vitae and morte”, after death, “vita” is crossed out.

Scatological.

High les garsh.... Lübeck. Jesus in an almond in the middle, patrons in circles surrounding, so it's clear in mass who to pray for.

Queen Elizabeth's reign – forbid idolatry. Commemorative institutions not much liked by protestants.

Alice transi. When praying, transi was visible because kneeling.

Many wanted to be close to the mass after death.

Priest with initials (HP) on the back of his coat, so that as he turned to face the alter, back to the congregation, the initials were clear to him.

Symbolic proximity to christ + it impresses the congregation.

Sacraments (of all, mass was most important).

Norwich – investment in hereafter.

Bishop Goldwell's arms next to personal chantry. Bishop in the dance of death in stained glass. When the protestants smashed up the place, they left behind this 1 panel untouched because it showed a catholic being taken away by death.

St Mary's in Winchester – 8 places were reserved for patron's servants. Don't want any old riff raff poor praying for you.

The idea of leprosy as unclean came with the victorians.

Christ looked like and loved the leper. Lepers go straight to heaven, so they're particularly blessed (that is, leper prayer is high quality prayer, but only if we're talking a devout leper.)

Grunwald crucifixion. St Augustine christus medicus.

Hospitals function often changed quickly – leprosarium, school, alms, hospital...

Medieval hospitals didn't cure, there was almost no medical staff working (none in england). Main treatment focused on air, diet, cleanliness, passion of the soul: music, all the time in St. Giles. Management of disease. Healthy environment. They wouldn't take the wounded – blood was sacrilegious. Wouldn't take those with infectious diseases. Again, holistic nature of medieval medicine. Prevention (through healthy diet etc) rather than cure. If the patient prayed, they were more likely to get better because they would not be anxious.

The charitable institution also buried its dead. It was a privilege to die in hospital, in the arms of the church. In those days, it was not a failure when the patient died, as it is now. Patient was given cross to hold.

The medieval believed disease to be spread on “corrupt air”.

The mind worked on a balance of the humours.

Some hospitals were attacked in the peasant revolt. (They were a waste of money, spending on patrons rather than patients).

PANEL C

JAMES HALL: THE RENAISSANCE ARTIST AS ANATOMIST: BANDINELLI, MICHELANGELO AND THE VOGUE FOR CREATIVE DESTRUCTION

Bandinelli, Self Portrait (1528-30).

Dissecting sculptor shows power over life and death + understands body.

Picasso – every act of creation is first an act of destruction.

Bandinelli first to accord demi-urgic powers.

Bandinelli's Self Portrait (1544). Colossus. In this one he became male not female, aggressive not tranquil, Michaelangelo not...

Grasping Hercules' head. He is an upgraded Hercules. Iconoclast? Creator? Dissatisfied sculptor?

Donatello Sacrifice of Isaac from Cathedral Bell Tower.

Holbein Erasmus with Terminus (c.1520-25).

Bandinelli Self Portrait (1548), hemmed in on all sides. Time has destroyed and is destroying antique sculpture but BB will recreate!

Rise of anatomical dissection BUT remained controversial into the 16th cent. Some said “Barbaric, unchristian!” others that it “revealed wonders of god's creation”.

Michelangelo compares himself often to weapons in his poetry. Bent Syrian bow, physical hardship, shoots through crooked barrel, explodes like a canon...

Leonardo's riddle - “Alas, I see the saviour crucified once more!” Solution – sculptor carving crucifix.

Francesco Salviati Portrait of a Goldsmith (1528).

Pathos in anatomical study.

17-18th cent. artist, creator/destroyer.

Artist posing with antique head fragment, head in pain. Shows respect for antique but also expressive progression (Van Dych Iconologia 1520s). Distressed female head most popular.

Superiority over classics. yeah.

TERESA LOUSA: WHAT ABOUT CORPSE AS ARTISTIC RESOURCE?

Andres Serrano. Teresa Margulles (tongue). Is corpse as art one of last taboos left? Pushing boundaries? Teresa Lousa thinks “Yes”.

NIGEL LLEWELLYN: BRONZE BODIES

(Introduced by Maya Warrior – head of theology, religion, philosophy).

West Hill Cemetery, Winchester. A team including Tina are mapping the cemetery.

Event – Death In Scotland (January).

Medieval effigies with crossed feet = crusades.

Thanotology? Rather 'Death Studies'.

Intolerance to accept existing boundaries.

Old way = death as moment. No. Medical science disconnects moment, makes period.

We cannot separate body from art.

Thinking about links between then & now, universality, be careful!! Can trigger responses...

Need big framing ideas. TIME. Social science. Rejects life/death binary, rather “dying”. Anthropologists. Length of timeline, timeline approach helps more than binary does (individuals + cultures). Ritual needed.

Reformation ->1660 1/3rd of effigies are erected in lifetime of person commemorated.

Ancestors habitually erect monument to themselves. Time is frozen. 17 years between erection and death.

Leaving resources for chantry prayers but also funds for prayers during lifetime!

Art of Death at V and A. 20 years ago.

Monuments – starting point – function = monumental body. It fills a space left by death. Natural, social, (monumental) body. Cantorovitz split. “The King Is Dead.” “Long Live The King.” (ie natural body, social or political body.... successor lives).

What the person represents continues. Monuments are works of art which express what will be continues by the monument.

When looking at effigies, Nigel looks at 4 kinds of content: - sculpted body (effigial, subsidiary, allegorical); - architectural framing (canopies over chantries; - inscribed word; - heraldry.

THE WESTON MONUMENT.

Laudianism = kickback to puritan; dignity, procession, display; clergy separate, looked up to; “higher church”; vestments brought back; images SANCTIONED (2nd commandment but if didactic then they're fine).

But this was not done tastefully. I was hated in the 1830s because of the gothic revival. “The liberality if not the taste of a fox!”.

.........................................and so on............................

Talking at lunch with Romany – Agency of tree/stone grave ie agency of stillness. (X)LOOK UP – Arno Vale ... something... in a graveyard; trees and hybrid geographies, dwelling, monitoring and resistance in Bristol Cemetery. Paul Cloke + Owen Jones.

Hannah Harkes is an artist who works in two, three, and four dimensions.

Articles by admin